Misconceptions, also referred to as naïve conceptions, are ideas students have about
scientific concepts that are not scientifically accurate or are incomplete. These scientifically inaccurate
conceptions are often retained after instruction and into adulthood. The misconceptions identified here may relate
to content taught in earlier grades. The resources recommended should be incorporated into instruction in a
way that is developmentally appropriate and that corrects misconceptions as a part of standards-based instruction.
| Misconception | ORC Resources That Address the Misconception |
| Quest 1: The Universe, Forces and Motion, and the Nature of Matter |
| The universe is static and unchanging. | ORC #208: Amazing Space ORC #8100: Runaway Universe ORC #8488: Changing Faces: A Study of Solar and Planetary Rotation Rates ORC #9952: Spaceflight Now
|
|
| The sun will never burn out. | ORC #3493: ORC #9954: Star Life Cycle
|
|
| The universe is relatively new. | ORC #8100: Runaway Universe
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Student groups find information about the areas of research that provide evidence for the big bang theory (e.g., cosmic background radiation, red shift). Students report their findings using poster and PowerPoint presentations. |
|
| Matter is continuous (particles of matter do not have space between them). | ORC #2312: The Structure of Metal ORC #2393: See Inside a Diamond
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Give students materials to make models of compounds. Students should be able to see that it is not possible to join “atoms” in any configuration without having some space between them. |
|
| Atoms are alive because they move. | ORC #5008: Characteristics of Living Things
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Bring in toys that move. Ask students whether or not the toys are alive. Emphasize that just because something moves doesn’t mean that it is alive. Challenge students to think of other objects that move that are not alive. |
|
| Atoms have electrons circling them like planets around a star. | ORC #1635: NAEP Assessment Item, Grade 12 ORC #2393: See Inside a Diamond ORC #3790: Atom Builder
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Make sure that students understand the purpose and function of models in science. Discuss different models, and have students identify strengths and weaknesses of each model. |
|
| An applied force is required to keep an object moving. | ORC #41: Amusement Park Physics ORC #9375: The Physics Classroom ORC #9935: Student Difficulties in Physics Information Center
|
|
 Teacher Tips: With this fundamental law of physics in mind, have students release a ball on a ramp. Allow the ball to roll until it comes to rest on its own. Then discuss why the ball eventually stopped.
As a follow-up, discuss how planets in our solar system keep moving at essentially the same speed, but in a curved pathway. What is the force that causes the pathway to be curved (orbital)? The curved pathway is a result of the force of gravity (mainly from the sun). |
|
| Heavy objects fall faster than lighter objects (because the acceleration due to gravity is stronger on heavier objects). | ORC #424: Exploring Pendulums
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Have students drop a flat sheet of paper from a height of about 3 meters. It will flutter and float as it falls (accelerating due to gravity), taking perhaps a second or two to reach the floor. Next take that same sheet of paper, but wad it up into a tight ball as much as possible. (Don’t add any tape or other material). Now drop that wadded sheet of paper (the same mass and the same acceleration due to gravity g), and notice how it falls. It will reach the floor in perhaps less than a second. Why did it fall faster when wadded than when flat if mass and g didn’t change? Discuss air resistance with the students to help them understand this principle.
Extend this exploration by having students drop the wadded paper ball alongside a heavier, similar-shaped object. Or put a piece of flat paper on top of a book and drop them together. Have students observe that, in both scenarios, the objects fall at the same rate.
Drop 2 or 3 spheres of equal diameter but different mass simultaneously and from the same height. A 2.5-cm glass marble, steel ball, and wood ball work well. |
|
| Any force causes an object to accelerate. | ORC #3081: Friction
|
|
 Teacher Tips: One simple demonstration is to have a student push against a wall. The wall does not accelerate. |
|
| If an object moves at a constant velocity, no forces are acting upon it. | ORC #3081: Friction
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Use a car on a freeway as an example. The car can move at a constant velocity only if a force is applied. |
|
| Waves move material from one place to another. For example, water waves move water from one place on a lake to another place on the lake or the lakeshore. | |
|
 Teacher Tips: Have students place a small cork in a tub of water. Then have them disturb the water by quickly dipping a ruler or pencil tip in and out to create a wave pattern. Students should see that the cork just bobs up and down as the energy of the wave travels through the water as ripples.
Another activity could be to have two students hold the ends of a rope as one of the students moves his or her hands up and down to create a wave pattern through the rope. The rope remains strung between the two students—it doesn’t go anywhere—but the particles of the rope move up and down in a vibration-like motion. The energy is transferred through the rope from one person to the other. |
|
| A wave’s amplitude influences its speed. | ORC #8046: Star Light, Star Bright
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Have students use Slinky toys to disprove this misconception. |
|
|
| Quest 2: Earth Systems and Forces and Motion |
| Continents do not move. | ORC #39: Dive and Discover ORC #510: OhioSeis ORC #527: Musical Plates ORC #3469: Earth Movers ORC #8064: A Model of Sea-Floor Spreading
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Students plot magnetic reversal patterns along selected segments of the mid-ocean ridge. Through color-coding, students visualize centers of seafloor spreading. |
|
| Earth and space are separate entities. | ORC #40: Windows to the Universe ORC #8100: Runaway Universe
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Woring in groups, students do research on the relationships among the Earth’s spheres. Students report their findings using poster presentations. |
|
| The oxygen we breathe does not originate from plants. | ORC #9939: Illuminating Photosynthesis
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Students participate in an experiment with Elodea in water. |
|
| Ozone depletion and the greenhouse effect are the same thing. They both equally cause global warming. | ORC #3280: Air Pollution: What's the Solution?
|
|
| Certain complex properties like melting point, boiling point, and density are chemical properties. | ORC #564: Why does an ice cube float in water and not sink?
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Review with students the differences between chemical and physical properties. Have students predict whether melting point, boiling point, and density are chemical or physical properties. If students label any of these as chemical properties, ask students what happens when water melts or boils or when something floats or sinks (or demonstrate each). Ask students to identify where the substance has been changed chemically during the observation process. |
|
| Physical changes are reversible, while chemical changes are not reversible. | ORC #9958: The Blue Bottle Demonstration
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Have students perform an array of equilibrium reactions. This is also a good time to review the phase-change curve of water, discussing what is happening at each inflection point on the curve. |
|
| A chemical reaction occurs in isolation from its surroundings. | ORC #2392: Forever Wild? ORC #6159: Mobile Inquiry Technology: Monitoring an Aquarium
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Have students plant seeds in two different cups and change the amount of light each plant receives. Plant and water each set of seeds equally. Have students make observations about the health of each plant over the course of a couple of weeks. Review with students the chemical reactions taking place within a plant&em;photosynthesis and respiration&em;and have students identify how the environment is affecting these chemical reactions. The activity could also be done by changing the amount of carbon dioxide each receives. |
|
| There are exceptions to the laws of conservation of mass and energy. | ORC #2636: Chemical Reactions - Borax & Glue, Cream ORC #5217: Tutorial on Balancing Equations ORC #7302: NAEP Assessment Item, Grade 12
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Have students perform a laboratory activity that involves mixing baking soda and vinegar. Have students perform the reaction in an open system and then in a closed system (a large baggie). Have students compare masses before and after the reaction occurs. |
|
| Energy is lost when fuel is burned, objects slow and/or come to a stop, or people use it up in physical activity. | ORC #2326: Science of Sports: Spring Man ORC #2340: Building a Better Mousetrap Car
|
|
 Teacher Tips: Have students work with many kinds of devices or research the topic of energy within systems to learn about the ever-present form of thermal energy caused by friction.
Or have students investigate the use of fuels as energy resources. Another strategy is to have students discuss energy transformations within electrical generating and distribution systems, energy levels within food webs, and the human body’s natural cooling process. Ask what happens to energy during processes and within systems. |
|
|